Snorkeling is one of the most enjoyable ways to experience the beauty of the underwater world. From exploring coral reefs to gliding over shallow lagoons, it’s an activity that combines relaxation with adventure. But before you dip below the surface, one important decision awaits: Should you use a full face snorkel mask or a traditional snorkel tube with a mask?
This question is particularly common among beginners, but even seasoned snorkelers debate the pros and cons of each option. Both choices allow you to breathe while floating at the surface, but the design, comfort, safety, and overall experience can vary significantly.
In this blog, we’ll explore the differences between full face snorkel masks and traditional snorkel tubes, weigh their pros and cons, and help you decide which option is best for your needs.
What Is a Full Face Snorkel Mask?
A full face snorkel mask is a relatively new innovation in snorkeling gear. Unlike traditional setups, it covers the entire face, from the forehead down to the chin, combining the mask and snorkel into one piece.
Key Features:
Integrated snorkel system: The snorkel tube extends from the top of the mask.
Natural breathing: Users can breathe through both nose and mouth.
Panoramic view: Large lens provides a 180-degree field of vision.
Dry-top technology: Prevents water from entering the snorkel.
Separate airflow system: Reduces fogging by channeling air circulation.
This design was created with beginners in mind, aiming to make snorkeling easier and more comfortable.
What Is a Traditional Snorkel Tube?
The traditional snorkel tube, often paired with a separate mask, has been around for decades and is the gear of choice for many experienced snorkelers and divers.
Key Features:
Separate mask and snorkel: The mask covers the eyes and nose, while the snorkel tube goes into the mouth.
Breathing through mouth: Users inhale and exhale solely via the mouthpiece.
Simple, lightweight design: Easy to carry, adjust, and replace parts.
Free diving compatibility: Allows you to dive beneath the surface by clearing water from the snorkel.
While it requires more practice than a full face mask, it remains popular for its versatility and effectiveness.
Pros and Cons of Full Face Snorkel Masks
Pros
1. Natural Breathing
One of the biggest advantages is the ability to breathe through both your nose and mouth. This feels more comfortable and less restrictive, especially for beginners who aren’t used to clenching a snorkel mouthpiece.
2. Panoramic Vision
The large lens offers a wide-angle view, making the underwater scenery feel more immersive. Beginners, in particular, appreciate the unobstructed field of vision.
3. Reduced Fogging
The dual airflow system keeps the mask clearer by separating inhaled and exhaled air, minimizing fog buildup.
4. Comfort
Without a mouthpiece, there’s no jaw fatigue, making long snorkeling sessions more enjoyable.
5. Safety Features
Many models feature dry-top technology that automatically blocks water from entering the snorkel if submerged.
Cons
1. Not Suitable for Diving
Full face masks are designed for surface use only. Attempting to dive beneath the surface can create pressure issues and discomfort.
2. Bulkier Design
They’re heavier and more cumbersome to carry compared to traditional setups.
3. CO₂ Build-Up Risk
Poorly designed or cheap models may not have proper airflow systems, which can trap exhaled carbon dioxide, leading to dizziness or discomfort.
4. Higher Price
Full face masks are generally more expensive than traditional snorkel gear.
Pros and Cons of Traditional Snorkel Tubes
Pros
1. Versatility
Traditional snorkel setups allow you to dive underwater, resurface, and clear the snorkel with a simple blow. This makes them ideal for more adventurous snorkeling.
2. Compact and Lightweight
Easy to carry and pack, they’re perfect for travelers who want minimal gear.
3. Affordable
A good-quality mask and snorkel combo is usually more budget-friendly than a full face mask.
4. Replaceable Parts
If a snorkel tube or mask strap breaks, replacements are cheap and easy to find.
Cons
1. Unnatural Breathing
Breathing solely through the mouth takes practice and may feel uncomfortable at first.
2. Jaw Fatigue
Holding the mouthpiece can cause discomfort during longer snorkeling sessions.
3. Fogging Issues
Unless treated with anti-fog solutions, traditional masks can fog up quickly.
4. Learning Curve
Beginners may struggle with clearing water from the snorkel or adjusting to the breathing method.
Comfort and Ease of Use
Full Face Mask: Wins in terms of comfort, especially for beginners. Breathing is natural, and the lack of a mouthpiece eliminates jaw fatigue.
Traditional Tube: Takes more practice but offers flexibility once mastered.
Winner for Beginners: Full Face Mask.
Safety Considerations
Full Face Mask: Safe for surface snorkeling when bought from reputable brands. However, low-quality models may pose risks like CO₂ buildup. Not suitable for diving.
Traditional Tube: Offers safety for both surface and underwater use, provided the snorkeler learns how to clear the snorkel correctly.
Winner for Versatility: Traditional Tube.
Visibility and Breathing Experience
Full Face Mask: Provides a wide, panoramic view and natural breathing. Excellent for enjoying coral reefs and schools of fish without distraction.
Traditional Tube: Offers a narrower view and requires adjustment to mouth-only breathing.
Winner for Comfort and Visibility: Full Face Mask.
Maintenance and Durability
Full Face Mask: Cleaning requires extra care due to its larger size and built-in parts. Replacements can be costly if something breaks.
Traditional Tube: Easier to maintain, clean, and replace parts.
Winner for Practicality: Traditional Tube.
Cost and Accessibility
Full Face Mask: Generally more expensive, though prices are dropping as they become more popular.
Traditional Tube: More affordable and widely available.
Winner for Budget: Traditional Tube.
Who Should Choose a Full Face Snorkel Mask?
Beginners who want an easy, stress-free introduction to snorkeling.
Casual snorkelers who plan to stay at the surface.
Travelers who prioritize comfort and panoramic views.
Who Should Choose a Traditional Snorkel Tube?
Adventurous snorkelers who want to dive below the surface.
Experienced users looking for versatility and control.
Budget-conscious travelers who value affordability and simplicity.
Final Thoughts: Which Is Better?
Both full face snorkel masks and traditional snorkel tubes have their place, and the “better” option ultimately depends on your goals.
If you’re a beginner who wants comfort, natural breathing, and a wide field of vision, the full face mask is a fantastic choice for surface snorkeling. Go to Greatever shop(greatever.com), choose your best full face snorkel mask
If you’re interested in diving beneath the surface or want versatile, budget-friendly gear, the traditional snorkel tube is the way to go.
Ultimately, the choice isn’t about which mask is superior overall—it’s about which one matches your snorkeling style. By understanding the pros and cons of each, you can make an informed decision and enjoy the underwater world with confidence.